The 2008 Scouting Report by the Fans for the Fans

2008 The Scouting Report, By the Fans, For the Fans

Player Pos Position-Specific Overall
Position-Neutral Instincts FirstStep Speed Hands Release Strength Accuracy Ballots Agreement
Level
Wilson, Jack SS 78 78 80 77 60 87 79 77 86 8 0.83
McLouth, Nate CF 64 61 65 59 76 65 56 39 63 11 0.58
Bay, Jason LF 57 56 58 56 59 57 57 49 57 81 0.72
LaRoche, Andy 3B 58 54 53 53 47 53 54 70 57 25 0.7
Chavez, Raul C 67 54 67 21 27 72 72 68 76 7 0.68
LaRoche, Adam 1B 55 52 53 35 16 74 68 61 72 8 0.73
Mientkiewicz, Doug 1B 53 51 57 37 38 68 55 53 49 7 0.71
Nady, Xavier RF 49 50 48 46 48 50 52 58 60 33 0.79
Moss, Brandon LF 48 48 45 49 50 42 49 53 49 48 0.82
Sanchez, Freddy 2B 50 48 52 51 44 54 45 28 62 9 0.55
Bautista, Jose 3B 50 46 43 41 38 44 49 71 40 8 0.48
Rivas, Luis SS 40 41 35 45 53 37 37 34 45 6 0.57
Michaels, Jason RF 38 38 36 42 38 42 35 33 33 18 0.76
Bixler, Brian SS 39 38 30 48 59 21 37 41 30 6 0.68
Gomez, Chris 2B 33 32 35 28 27 33 42 26 40 6 0.75
Doumit, Ryan C 32 30 35 35 27 3 21 62 37 8 0.72
Pearce, Steve RF 28 28 30 25 33 25 24 38 17 6 0.69
Paulino, Ronny C 23 20 14 15 15 19 26 45 17 7 0.48

Update: Nov 25, 2008

The league average for each of the seven traits of fielding is fixed at 50, with one standard deviation equal to 20 points. This means that a player with a trait value of 70 is in the top 16% in the league.

A player's name in gray means the player received less than 3 votes. A player's name in red received less than 6 votes.

The higher the agreement level, the more that the fans agreed with each other in the balloting. The league average is .71. The league low is around .40.

Player	Pos	Position-Specific	Overall Position-Neutral	Instincts	FirstStep	Speed	Hands	Release	Strength	Accuracy	Ballots	Agreement Level
Wilson, Jack	SS	78	78	80	77	60	87	79	77	86	8	0.83
McLouth, Nate	CF	64	61	65	59	76	65	56	39	63	11	0.58
Bay, Jason	LF	57	56	58	56	59	57	57	49	57	81	0.72
LaRoche, Andy	3B	58	54	53	53	47	53	54	70	57	25	0.7
Chavez, Raul	C	67	54	67	21	27	72	72	68	76	7	0.68
LaRoche, Adam	1B	55	52	53	35	16	74	68	61	72	8	0.73
Mientkiewicz, Doug	1B	53	51	57	37	38	68	55	53	49	7	0.71
Nady, Xavier	RF	49	50	48	46	48	50	52	58	60	33	0.79
Moss, Brandon	LF	48	48	45	49	50	42	49	53	49	48	0.82
Sanchez, Freddy	2B	50	48	52	51	44	54	45	28	62	9	0.55
Bautista, Jose	3B	50	46	43	41	38	44	49	71	40	8	0.48
Rivas, Luis	SS	40	41	35	45	53	37	37	34	45	6	0.57
Michaels, Jason	RF	38	38	36	42	38	42	35	33	33	18	0.76
Bixler, Brian	SS	39	38	30	48	59	21	37	41	30	6	0.68
Gomez, Chris	2B	33	32	35	28	27	33	42	26	40	6	0.75
Doumit, Ryan	C	32	30	35	35	27	3	21	62	37	8	0.72
Pearce, Steve	RF	28	28	30	25	33	25	24	38	17	6	0.69
Paulino, Ronny	C	23	20	14	15	15	19	26	45	17	7	0.48