2008 The Scouting Report, By the Fans, For the Fans

©Tangotiger

See all teams

Player	Pos	Position-Specific	Overall Position-Neutral	Instincts	FirstStep	Speed	Hands	Release	Strength	Accuracy	Ballots	Agreement Level
McDonald, John	SS	87	86	93	85	68	90	97	71	94	45	0.85
Vizquel, Omar	SS	82	81	92	78	65	93	100	38	95	52	0.73
Furcal, Rafael	SS	81	81	80	86	86	72	77	91	77	29	0.82
Aybar, Erick	SS	81	80	86	91	85	69	72	86	61	14	0.84
Reyes, Jose	SS	78	78	71	84	89	68	73	91	74	51	0.75
Wilson, Jack	SS	78	78	80	77	60	87	79	77	86	8	0.83
Tulowitzki, Troy	SS	78	77	79	72	58	78	81	95	83	11	0.8
Greene, Khalil	SS	76	75	75	75	59	83	83	76	76	62	0.77
Bartlett, Jason	SS	76	75	79	78	69	74	86	64	67	56	0.78
Rollins, Jimmy	SS	74	74	75	79	81	66	72	69	75	24	0.77
Hu, Chin-lung	SS	71	72	72	74	66	78	71	63	76	28	0.72
Escobar, Yunel	SS	71	70	74	69	62	68	71	84	63	25	0.72
Izturis, Cesar	SS	70	70	67	71	68	71	75	64	75	57	0.76
Gonzalez, Alberto	SS	70	70	68	67	64	74	76	65	76	14	0.71
Izturis, Maicer	SS	70	70	70	68	68	74	77	54	79	13	0.79
Janish, Paul	SS	70	69	68	68	58	73	77	69	72	21	0.78
Hardy, J.J.	SS	69	68	73	55	46	78	80	78	80	26	0.79
Pena Jr., Tony	SS	68	67	74	71	54	61	65	76	65	24	0.7
Cabrera, Orlando	SS	67	66	69	64	63	67	78	49	77	38	0.8
Castro, Juan	SS	67	66	72	58	54	75	76	56	75	45	0.72
Punto, Nick	SS	65	65	61	71	65	73	63	53	65	26	0.63
Bocock, Brian	SS	65	65	67	59	59	68	72	63	68	27	0.69
Burriss, Emmanuel	SS	64	65	61	74	84	53	58	59	61	42	0.75
Santiago, Ramon	SS	64	64	62	68	67	61	66	57	68	42	0.82
Lillibridge, Brent	SS	64	64	61	76	78	51	61	56	63	11	0.67
Ramirez, Hanley	SS	63	64	72	76	85	43	42	77	33	22	0.64
Drew, Stephen	SS	63	62	62	63	63	58	67	59	61	38	0.78
Quintanilla, Omar	SS	62	63	67	72	61	65	57	44	62	10	0.82
Everett, Adam	SS	62	60	74	69	57	78	78	4	25	16	0.68
Ochoa, Ivan	SS	60	60	59	60	61	64	63	53	62	27	0.75
Tejada, Miguel	SS	57	56	60	50	45	56	64	64	65	18	0.66
Wood, Brandon	SS	56	57	57	57	58	51	42	75	64	8	0.79
Tolbert, Matt	SS	56	56	57	54	66	51	57	48	64	4	0.62
Crosby, Bobby	SS	55	56	58	54	57	56	48	68	45	35	0.62
Hairston Jr., Jerry	SS	53	54	53	62	67	47	50	38	48	29	0.81
Lowrie, Jed	SS	53	53	54	52	50	55	55	49	59	90	0.82
Jeter, Derek	SS	53	53	51	35	56	61	59	64	56	78	0.53
Ryan, Brendan	SS	52	53	48	60	69	42	45	55	45	43	0.79
Scutaro, Marco	SS	52	52	50	52	53	52	57	46	54	37	0.81
Theriot, Ryan	SS	52	52	53	58	63	51	53	26	48	57	0.65
Guzman, Cristian	SS	52	52	52	50	54	49	56	45	60	26	0.65
Aviles, Mike	SS	52	51	58	48	50	47	53	51	47	23	0.73
Rodriguez, Luis	SS	51	51	53	52	52	52	52	41	53	27	0.69
Garciaparra, Nomar	SS	48	48	49	44	43	54	49	48	52	29	0.6
Young, Michael	SS	48	48	40	28	41	53	63	65	70	17	0.55
Berroa, Angel	SS	47	47	43	53	52	43	46	43	47	27	0.66
Fahey, Brandon	SS	46	46	46	48	50	44	48	34	45	42	0.65
Zobrist, Ben	SS	44	45	41	49	52	38	42	41	51	42	0.72
Bruntlett, Eric	SS	44	44	43	45	49	39	47	41	42	15	0.82
Cora, Alex	SS	44	44	46	40	42	39	51	41	51	76	0.66
Keppinger, Jeff	SS	42	42	37	34	41	50	51	38	57	41	0.73
Rivas, Luis	SS	40	41	35	45	53	37	37	34	45	6	0.57
Lugo, Julio	SS	39	40	39	59	70	18	18	47	11	115	0.68
Peralta, Jhonny	SS	39	40	29	27	29	48	46	65	56	36	0.52
Betancourt, Yuniesky	SS	39	39	39	39	50	38	29	60	8	151	0.52
Bixler, Brian	SS	39	38	30	48	59	21	37	41	30	6	0.68
Harris, Brendan	SS	37	37	34	34	47	30	34	47	39	25	0.73
Eckstein, David	SS	37	36	43	44	46	37	38	0	29	34	0.68
Orr, Pete	SS	36	36	38	34	42	31	42	31	27	5	0.67
Renteria, Edgar	SS	35	35	33	26	33	35	44	34	49	63	0.66
Hernandez, Luis	SS	34	35	29	43	45	32	26	40	25	40	0.55
Bynum, Freddie	SS	30	32	18	56	67	7	11	39	13	37	0.6
Cintron, Alex	SS	15	16	15	24	33	6	7	11	6	44	0.67

---

Update: Nov 25, 2008

The league average for each of the seven traits of fielding is fixed at 50, with one standard deviation equal to 20 points. This means that a player with a trait value of 70 is in the top 16% in the league.

A player's name in gray means the player received less than 3 votes. A player's name in red received less than 6 votes.

The higher the agreement level, the more that the fans agreed with each other in the balloting. The league average is .71. The league low is around .40.