2008 The Scouting Report, By the Fans, For the Fans

©Tangotiger

See all teams

Player	Pos	Position-Specific	Overall Position-Neutral	Instincts	FirstStep	Speed	Hands	Release	Strength	Accuracy	Ballots	Agreement Level
Pujols, Albert	1B	78	73	92	67	46	88	81	56	78	74	0.74
Lee, Derrek	1B	74	70	82	64	57	87	72	54	70	59	0.69
Gonzalez, Adrian	1B	73	69	82	50	25	87	93	72	87	69	0.74
Teixeira, Mark	1B	71	67	83	63	49	80	64	55	66	33	0.7
Youkilis, Kevin	1B	69	65	77	56	41	85	69	56	68	128	0.77
Helton, Todd	1B	69	63	84	57	30	83	69	47	62	10	0.64
Overbay, Lyle	1B	67	65	66	58	40	74	74	75	79	20	0.74
Berkman, Lance	1B	66	64	78	58	48	71	65	59	64	18	0.68
Loney, James	1B	65	62	70	54	42	76	68	66	56	42	0.63
Kotchman, Casey	1B	65	60	73	55	36	83	57	50	57	25	0.68
Pena, Carlos	1B	63	59	70	50	40	78	64	51	61	53	0.7
Johnson, Nick	1B	59	57	64	43	39	71	69	53	67	8	0.82
Morneau, Justin	1B	58	55	66	44	37	72	56	51	57	26	0.74
Davis, Chris	1B	57	56	62	50	46	59	58	62	57	13	0.66
LaRoche, Adam	1B	55	52	53	35	16	74	68	61	72	8	0.73
Mientkiewicz, Doug	1B	53	51	57	37	38	68	55	53	49	7	0.71
Votto, Joey	1B	48	47	54	54	51	44	32	48	37	44	0.72
Aurilia, Rich	1B	48	46	51	40	32	52	55	44	50	41	0.73
Gload, Ross	1B	48	45	49	41	33	64	50	27	40	25	0.74
Barton, Daric	1B	46	46	52	45	43	41	42	54	49	23	0.57
Cairo, Miguel	1B	45	44	46	45	45	47	45	32	44	80	0.63
Bankston, Wes	1B	43	43	43	43	40	44	42	50	40	3	0.39
Millar, Kevin	1B	41	37	46	22	17	64	44	25	38	60	0.67
Tracy, Chad	1B	39	39	44	33	37	41	38	44	34	32	0.69
Cabrera, Miguel	1B	37	37	38	19	19	45	39	66	50	64	0.68
Casey, Sean	1B	37	34	40	22	17	48	44	35	42	55	0.76
Blalock, Hank	1B	35	34	31	20	30	50	39	33	50	10	0.62
LaHair, Bryan	1B	35	34	32	31	30	40	38	36	35	39	0.76
Bowker, John	1B	34	37	27	41	46	30	29	48	42	32	0.75
Betemit, Wilson	1B	34	36	32	36	40	28	36	44	45	34	0.73
Boone, Aaron	1B	33	32	36	28	35	33	34	30	32	7	0.54
Casto, Kory	1B	32	33	26	38	39	31	25	36	33	9	0.7
Catalanotto, Frank	1B	30	29	32	32	31	30	29	15	24	12	0.62
Garko, Ryan	1B	29	28	29	20	15	36	29	35	40	26	0.63
Konerko, Paul	1B	29	26	35	10	10	44	30	33	30	32	0.69
Delgado, Carlos	1B	26	24	25	17	19	43	24	20	20	39	0.64
Duncan, Shelley	1B	23	25	21	19	30	18	18	52	35	13	0.67
Butler, Billy	1B	23	23	24	17	16	30	15	35	26	23	0.68
Valentin, Javier	1B	18	18	21	13	17	23	13	21	17	18	0.67
Giambi, Jason	1B	18	16	26	16	15	28	1	12	0	59	0.64
Broussard, Ben	1B	17	18	13	13	22	23	23	22	8	7	0.58
Howard, Ryan	1B	17	18	24	14	25	13	7	33	7	22	0.58
Sexson, Richie	1B	17	17	8	10	15	27	18	25	25	96	0.64
Fielder, Prince	1B	16	18	25	12	22	3	19	30	30	26	0.72
Shelton, Chris	1B	16	16	9	15	15	25	16	19	17	7	0.65
Jacobs, Mike	1B	15	17	17	17	19	5	18	30	21	19	0.65
Young, Dmitri	1B	12	11	15	3	11	22	4	12	15	12	0.7

---

Update: Nov 25, 2008

The league average for each of the seven traits of fielding is fixed at 50, with one standard deviation equal to 20 points. This means that a player with a trait value of 70 is in the top 16% in the league.

A player's name in gray means the player received less than 3 votes. A player's name in red received less than 6 votes.

The higher the agreement level, the more that the fans agreed with each other in the balloting. The league average is .71. The league low is around .40.