The 2007 Scouting Report by the Fans for the Fans

2007 The Scouting Report, By the Fans, For the Fans

Player Pos Overall
Position-Neutral Instincts FirstStep Speed Hands Release Strength Accuracy Ballots Agreement
Level
Ellis, Mark 2B 81 87 81 61 91 98 55 92 54 0.84
Hudson, Orlando 2B 79 88 81 69 82 83 61 79 32 0.82
Phillips, Brandon 2B 78 78 81 79 74 84 76 72 25 0.81
Roberts, Brian 2B 77 82 81 82 75 79 55 74 52 0.78
Polanco, Placido 2B 74 82 67 53 90 87 54 89 54 0.83
Hill, Aaron 2B 72 79 72 59 71 78 70 81 97 0.82
Utley, Chase 2B 70 77 74 68 69 74 55 66 34 0.82
Castillo, Luis 2B 66 72 58 57 78 73 50 77 48 0.72
Matsui, Kazuo 2B 66 63 77 74 63 62 45 68 13 0.82
Upton, B.J. 2B 66 62 69 84 64 46 75 51 29 0.52
Barfield, Josh 2B 64 68 69 70 62 59 50 57 29 0.69
Grudzielanek, Mark 2B 64 71 53 39 81 83 52 80 20 0.77
Izturis, Maicer 2B 64 64 68 65 67 64 55 62 20 0.8
Pedroia, Dustin 2B 63 70 62 44 68 73 52 72 277 0.79
Aybar, Erick 2B 61 58 77 79 43 48 64 45 19 0.62
Carroll, Jamey 2B 61 63 59 54 67 72 46 65 12 0.67
Valentin, Jose 2B 61 68 61 49 62 67 51 66 19 0.65
Giles, Marcus 2B 60 64 60 59 65 64 40 61 16 0.71
Quintanilla, Omar 2B 59 54 68 58 65 58 41 62 7 0.77
Richar, Danny 2B 59 65 72 73 40 45 57 53 6 0.65
DeRosa, Mark 2B 58 59 55 53 64 64 50 66 27 0.82
Lopez, Jose 2B 58 58 57 52 60 60 56 67 296 0.74
Casilla, Alexi 2B 57 45 77 85 35 44 61 35 18 0.68
Cora, Alex 2B 57 60 56 54 59 61 46 60 217 0.81
Johnson, Kelly 2B 57 56 63 60 45 56 53 66 30 0.66
Cano, Robinson 2B 55 52 57 55 47 54 67 63 68 0.66
Iguchi, Tadahito 2B 55 59 55 56 55 61 43 55 32 0.8
Kendrick, Howie 2B 55 58 60 65 43 48 55 53 20 0.84
Burke, Chris 2B 54 52 62 66 49 53 37 46 16 0.75
Sanchez, Freddy 2B 54 53 53 47 67 48 46 71 12 0.63
Graffanino, Tony 2B 53 50 47 46 63 59 45 65 17 0.81
Fontenot, Mike 2B 51 45 57 60 40 53 48 52 20 0.7
Martinez, Ramon 2B 51 53 48 50 54 56 42 57 28 0.72
Raburn, Ryan 2B 51 49 58 59 45 44 53 44 27 0.76
Belliard, Ronnie 2B 50 55 46 42 52 62 44 53 33 0.72
Kennedy, Adam 2B 50 47 52 51 49 54 45 49 35 0.76
Infante, Omar 2B 49 48 57 60 44 44 35 48 33 0.76
Kinsler, Ian 2B 48 55 54 60 27 34 56 47 15 0.73
Wilson, Josh 2B 48 46 54 50 42 49 47 47 15 0.84
Rouse, Mike 2B 46 42 39 45 46 56 55 44 6 0.7
Frandsen, Kevin 2B 45 42 51 56 29 40 56 44 19 0.7
Uggla, Dan 2B 45 45 45 47 47 47 44 39 9 0.55
Weeks, Rickie 2B 43 35 62 75 19 28 51 17 20 0.56
Easley, Damion 2B 41 40 41 43 42 38 40 46 19 0.8
Durham, Ray 2B 39 37 44 48 20 41 38 53 39 0.65
Kent, Jeff 2B 39 42 22 20 44 57 48 62 59 0.64
Blum, Geoff 2B 38 35 34 34 36 44 44 45 10 0.62
Miles, Aaron 2B 37 36 44 48 27 39 30 29 45 0.7
German, Esteban 2B 35 28 49 59 19 24 32 26 17 0.74
Gotay, Ruben 2B 35 20 43 56 27 30 44 25 21 0.72
Biggio, Craig 2B 33 37 25 40 33 42 16 43 17 0.63

Final: Feb 8, 2008

The league average for each of the seven traits of fielding is fixed at 50, with one standard deviation equal to 20 points. This means that a player with a trait value of 70 is in the top 16% in the league.

A player's name in gray means the player received less than 3 votes. A player's name in red received less than 6 votes.

The higher the agreement level, the more that the fans agreed with each other in the balloting. The league average is .71. The league low is around .40.

Player	Pos	Overall Position-Neutral	Instincts	FirstStep	Speed	Hands	Release	Strength	Accuracy	Ballots	Agreement Level
Ellis, Mark	2B	81	87	81	61	91	98	55	92	54	0.84
Hudson, Orlando	2B	79	88	81	69	82	83	61	79	32	0.82
Phillips, Brandon	2B	78	78	81	79	74	84	76	72	25	0.81
Roberts, Brian	2B	77	82	81	82	75	79	55	74	52	0.78
Polanco, Placido	2B	74	82	67	53	90	87	54	89	54	0.83
Hill, Aaron	2B	72	79	72	59	71	78	70	81	97	0.82
Utley, Chase	2B	70	77	74	68	69	74	55	66	34	0.82
Castillo, Luis	2B	66	72	58	57	78	73	50	77	48	0.72
Matsui, Kazuo	2B	66	63	77	74	63	62	45	68	13	0.82
Upton, B.J.	2B	66	62	69	84	64	46	75	51	29	0.52
Barfield, Josh	2B	64	68	69	70	62	59	50	57	29	0.69
Grudzielanek, Mark	2B	64	71	53	39	81	83	52	80	20	0.77
Izturis, Maicer	2B	64	64	68	65	67	64	55	62	20	0.8
Pedroia, Dustin	2B	63	70	62	44	68	73	52	72	277	0.79
Aybar, Erick	2B	61	58	77	79	43	48	64	45	19	0.62
Carroll, Jamey	2B	61	63	59	54	67	72	46	65	12	0.67
Valentin, Jose	2B	61	68	61	49	62	67	51	66	19	0.65
Giles, Marcus	2B	60	64	60	59	65	64	40	61	16	0.71
Quintanilla, Omar	2B	59	54	68	58	65	58	41	62	7	0.77
Richar, Danny	2B	59	65	72	73	40	45	57	53	6	0.65
DeRosa, Mark	2B	58	59	55	53	64	64	50	66	27	0.82
Lopez, Jose	2B	58	58	57	52	60	60	56	67	296	0.74
Casilla, Alexi	2B	57	45	77	85	35	44	61	35	18	0.68
Cora, Alex	2B	57	60	56	54	59	61	46	60	217	0.81
Johnson, Kelly	2B	57	56	63	60	45	56	53	66	30	0.66
Cano, Robinson	2B	55	52	57	55	47	54	67	63	68	0.66
Iguchi, Tadahito	2B	55	59	55	56	55	61	43	55	32	0.8
Kendrick, Howie	2B	55	58	60	65	43	48	55	53	20	0.84
Burke, Chris	2B	54	52	62	66	49	53	37	46	16	0.75
Sanchez, Freddy	2B	54	53	53	47	67	48	46	71	12	0.63
Graffanino, Tony	2B	53	50	47	46	63	59	45	65	17	0.81
Fontenot, Mike	2B	51	45	57	60	40	53	48	52	20	0.7
Martinez, Ramon	2B	51	53	48	50	54	56	42	57	28	0.72
Raburn, Ryan	2B	51	49	58	59	45	44	53	44	27	0.76
Belliard, Ronnie	2B	50	55	46	42	52	62	44	53	33	0.72
Kennedy, Adam	2B	50	47	52	51	49	54	45	49	35	0.76
Infante, Omar	2B	49	48	57	60	44	44	35	48	33	0.76
Kinsler, Ian	2B	48	55	54	60	27	34	56	47	15	0.73
Wilson, Josh	2B	48	46	54	50	42	49	47	47	15	0.84
Rouse, Mike	2B	46	42	39	45	46	56	55	44	6	0.7
Frandsen, Kevin	2B	45	42	51	56	29	40	56	44	19	0.7
Uggla, Dan	2B	45	45	45	47	47	47	44	39	9	0.55
Weeks, Rickie	2B	43	35	62	75	19	28	51	17	20	0.56
Easley, Damion	2B	41	40	41	43	42	38	40	46	19	0.8
Durham, Ray	2B	39	37	44	48	20	41	38	53	39	0.65
Kent, Jeff	2B	39	42	22	20	44	57	48	62	59	0.64
Blum, Geoff	2B	38	35	34	34	36	44	44	45	10	0.62
Miles, Aaron	2B	37	36	44	48	27	39	30	29	45	0.7
German, Esteban	2B	35	28	49	59	19	24	32	26	17	0.74
Gotay, Ruben	2B	35	20	43	56	27	30	44	25	21	0.72
Biggio, Craig	2B	33	37	25	40	33	42	16	43	17	0.63