The 2006 Scouting Report by the Fans for the Fans

2006 The Scouting Report, By the Fans, For the Fans

Player Pos Overall
Position-Neutral Instincts FirstStep Speed Hands Release Strength Accuracy Ballots Agreement
Level
Teixeira, Mark 1B 75 92 74 51 84 75 68 74 16 0.8
Lee, Derrek 1B 75 85 75 66 90 73 57 71 35 0.75
Loney, James 1B 72 83 70 48 80 78 74 73 9 0.84
Mientkiewicz, Doug 1B 69 85 67 49 85 77 43 59 15 0.71
Pujols, Albert 1B 68 81 66 48 79 73 61 65 45 0.71
Gonzalez, Adrian 1B 64 80 57 26 87 71 54 70 14 0.7
Helton, Todd 1B 62 77 52 35 82 69 54 61 14 0.72
Snow, J.T. 1B 58 71 50 36 78 65 41 54 30 0.7
Lee, Travis 1B 58 62 62 38 73 71 36 51 6 0.48
Kotchman, Casey 1B 58 64 64 40 75 56 41 51 5 0.48
Garciaparra, Nomar 1B 58 61 59 52 58 52 64 62 12 0.72
Shealy, Ryan 1B 57 62 53 46 65 59 54 58 9 0.77
Overbay, Lyle 1B 57 63 53 40 70 56 52 62 48 0.72
Berkman, Lance 1B 54 57 49 45 56 57 59 58 18 0.72
Youkilis, Kevin 1B 54 61 50 35 65 56 53 59 125 0.8
Kendrick, Howie 1B 52 56 64 62 36 45 45 43 6 0.73
Helms, Wes 1B 52 56 44 47 55 56 59 54 6 0.87
Phillips, Andy 1B 51 51 49 44 59 51 51 48 24 0.74
Morales, Kendry 1B 51 59 56 47 50 53 46 39 5 0.82
Johnson, Nick 1B 49 67 49 41 52 48 43 32 19 0.64
Gload, Ross 1B 48 54 52 47 52 39 37 40 23 0.68
LaRoche, Adam 1B 47 46 31 18 65 60 64 61 17 0.54
Morneau, Justin 1B 44 53 38 32 50 46 44 49 40 0.67
Hernandez, Jose 1B 42 38 46 41 43 46 41 41 11 0.66
Casey, Sean 1B 42 53 26 20 62 48 41 47 54 0.64
Quinlan, Robb 1B 42 47 39 42 43 37 44 47 7 0.76
Franco, Julio 1B 40 46 39 37 36 49 31 35 7 0.7
Konerko, Paul 1B 39 38 22 12 63 51 47 57 33 0.69
Lamb, Mike 1B 38 39 42 42 27 32 43 39 13 0.81
Clark, Tony 1B 38 48 20 16 63 51 32 39 15 0.64
Wilson, Craig 1B 37 32 35 39 36 36 44 39 29 0.69
Sexson, Richie 1B 37 41 27 21 49 41 42 43 179 0.7
Hatteberg, Scott 1B 36 35 31 25 49 45 30 38 27 0.7
Niekro, Lance 1B 36 37 41 29 45 29 34 27 21 0.52
Fielder, Prince 1B 35 38 29 36 31 38 38 43 26 0.67
Shelton, Chris 1B 34 41 26 23 44 37 33 34 49 0.71
Jacobs, Mike 1B 34 33 24 29 31 41 46 51 6 0.6
Howard, Ryan 1B 34 39 33 30 36 27 42 33 27 0.64
Marrero, Eli 1B 34 38 48 40 12 23 36 33 5 0.42
Perez, Eduardo 1B 33 27 24 35 36 35 36 48 10 0.6
Johnson, Dan 1B 32 36 28 22 36 38 31 39 30 0.71
Sweeney, Mark 1B 31 38 34 27 28 33 27 29 23 0.73
Conine, Jeff 1B 31 37 19 24 30 39 34 47 17 0.73
Stairs, Matt 1B 29 37 9 25 30 23 46 51 5 0.7
Jordan, Brian 1B 28 29 30 45 21 26 15 31 4 0.54
Delgado, Carlos 1B 28 23 22 26 41 30 26 27 20 0.66
Jackson, Conor 1B 28 25 35 30 28 17 34 22 20 0.67
Broussard, Ben 1B 28 22 25 29 27 23 34 43 16 0.66
Mabry, John 1B 26 25 17 24 26 33 32 34 23 0.67
Hillenbrand, Shea 1B 25 21 26 31 14 24 37 28 59 0.69
Millar, Kevin 1B 23 25 18 17 23 23 31 35 17 0.74
Nevin, Phil 1B 21 15 16 17 22 17 41 34 19 0.71
Giambi, Jason 1B 16 26 9 13 35 6 11 0 40 0.55
Saenz, Olmedo 1B 15 16 8 11 21 11 28 20 8 0.65

Final: Nov 30, 2006

The league average for each of the seven traits of fielding is fixed at 50, with one standard deviation equal to 20 points. This means that a player with a trait value of 70 is in the top 16% in the league.

A player's name in gray means the player received less than 3 votes. A player's name in red received less than 6 votes.

The higher the agreement level, the more that the fans agreed with each other in the balloting. The league average is .71. The league low is around .40.

Player	Pos	Overall Position-Neutral	Instincts	FirstStep	Speed	Hands	Release	Strength	Accuracy	Ballots	Agreement Level
Teixeira, Mark	1B	75	92	74	51	84	75	68	74	16	0.8
Lee, Derrek	1B	75	85	75	66	90	73	57	71	35	0.75
Loney, James	1B	72	83	70	48	80	78	74	73	9	0.84
Mientkiewicz, Doug	1B	69	85	67	49	85	77	43	59	15	0.71
Pujols, Albert	1B	68	81	66	48	79	73	61	65	45	0.71
Gonzalez, Adrian	1B	64	80	57	26	87	71	54	70	14	0.7
Helton, Todd	1B	62	77	52	35	82	69	54	61	14	0.72
Snow, J.T.	1B	58	71	50	36	78	65	41	54	30	0.7
Lee, Travis	1B	58	62	62	38	73	71	36	51	6	0.48
Kotchman, Casey	1B	58	64	64	40	75	56	41	51	5	0.48
Garciaparra, Nomar	1B	58	61	59	52	58	52	64	62	12	0.72
Shealy, Ryan	1B	57	62	53	46	65	59	54	58	9	0.77
Overbay, Lyle	1B	57	63	53	40	70	56	52	62	48	0.72
Berkman, Lance	1B	54	57	49	45	56	57	59	58	18	0.72
Youkilis, Kevin	1B	54	61	50	35	65	56	53	59	125	0.8
Kendrick, Howie	1B	52	56	64	62	36	45	45	43	6	0.73
Helms, Wes	1B	52	56	44	47	55	56	59	54	6	0.87
Phillips, Andy	1B	51	51	49	44	59	51	51	48	24	0.74
Morales, Kendry	1B	51	59	56	47	50	53	46	39	5	0.82
Johnson, Nick	1B	49	67	49	41	52	48	43	32	19	0.64
Gload, Ross	1B	48	54	52	47	52	39	37	40	23	0.68
LaRoche, Adam	1B	47	46	31	18	65	60	64	61	17	0.54
Morneau, Justin	1B	44	53	38	32	50	46	44	49	40	0.67
Hernandez, Jose	1B	42	38	46	41	43	46	41	41	11	0.66
Casey, Sean	1B	42	53	26	20	62	48	41	47	54	0.64
Quinlan, Robb	1B	42	47	39	42	43	37	44	47	7	0.76
Franco, Julio	1B	40	46	39	37	36	49	31	35	7	0.7
Konerko, Paul	1B	39	38	22	12	63	51	47	57	33	0.69
Lamb, Mike	1B	38	39	42	42	27	32	43	39	13	0.81
Clark, Tony	1B	38	48	20	16	63	51	32	39	15	0.64
Wilson, Craig	1B	37	32	35	39	36	36	44	39	29	0.69
Sexson, Richie	1B	37	41	27	21	49	41	42	43	179	0.7
Hatteberg, Scott	1B	36	35	31	25	49	45	30	38	27	0.7
Niekro, Lance	1B	36	37	41	29	45	29	34	27	21	0.52
Fielder, Prince	1B	35	38	29	36	31	38	38	43	26	0.67
Shelton, Chris	1B	34	41	26	23	44	37	33	34	49	0.71
Jacobs, Mike	1B	34	33	24	29	31	41	46	51	6	0.6
Howard, Ryan	1B	34	39	33	30	36	27	42	33	27	0.64
Marrero, Eli	1B	34	38	48	40	12	23	36	33	5	0.42
Perez, Eduardo	1B	33	27	24	35	36	35	36	48	10	0.6
Johnson, Dan	1B	32	36	28	22	36	38	31	39	30	0.71
Sweeney, Mark	1B	31	38	34	27	28	33	27	29	23	0.73
Conine, Jeff	1B	31	37	19	24	30	39	34	47	17	0.73
Stairs, Matt	1B	29	37	9	25	30	23	46	51	5	0.7
Jordan, Brian	1B	28	29	30	45	21	26	15	31	4	0.54
Delgado, Carlos	1B	28	23	22	26	41	30	26	27	20	0.66
Jackson, Conor	1B	28	25	35	30	28	17	34	22	20	0.67
Broussard, Ben	1B	28	22	25	29	27	23	34	43	16	0.66
Mabry, John	1B	26	25	17	24	26	33	32	34	23	0.67
Hillenbrand, Shea	1B	25	21	26	31	14	24	37	28	59	0.69
Millar, Kevin	1B	23	25	18	17	23	23	31	35	17	0.74
Nevin, Phil	1B	21	15	16	17	22	17	41	34	19	0.71
Giambi, Jason	1B	16	26	9	13	35	6	11	0	40	0.55
Saenz, Olmedo	1B	15	16	8	11	21	11	28	20	8	0.65