2004 The Scouting Report, By the Fans, For the Fans

Results for players who played on multiple teams. Results are split based on votes by team. The average difference is 9 points. Wiggington showed an overall 0 differential, while Mayne showed an overall differential of 26 points.

See all teams

Player	Age	GP	Overall Position-Neutral	Instincts	FirstStep	Speed	Hands	Release	Strength	Accuracy	Ballots	Agreement Level
Wigginton, Ty	NYN	79	40	35	35	39	41	45	46	41	12	0.7
Wigginton, Ty	PIT	49	40	26	32	29	37	55	67	49	2	0.75
Walker, Larry	COL	30	71	75	54	55	64	97	74	91	3	0.77
Walker, Larry	SLN	37	72	78	69	56	67	79	82	79	13	0.82
Cabrera, Orlando	BOS	55	79	83	83	74	76	80	71	78	94	0.83
Cabrera, Orlando	MON	96	77	84	79	71	67	87	67	81	6	0.72
Finley, Steve	ARI	100	66	75	64	66	76	69	47	56	9	0.47
Finley, Steve	LAN	54	68	75	71	66	71	67	55	65	13	0.76
Hidalgo, Richard	HOU	50	65	53	59	56	57	75	93	84	16	0.78
Hidalgo, Richard	NYN	84	63	57	60	56	56	65	89	74	16	0.81
Lo Duca, Paul	FLO	46	41	43	48	44	26	55	31	33	4	0.68
Lo Duca, Paul	LAN	87	43	47	50	40	51	36	34	32	12	0.64
Olerud, John	NYA	44	57	75	39	27	75	65	46	69	26	0.56
Olerud, John	SEA	72	59	53	43	19	90	81	53	85	8	0.61
Beltran, Carlos	HOU	86	82	84	86	87	81	83	64	78	21	0.77
Beltran, Carlos	KCA	66	79	85	91	86	80	72	59	67	15	0.75
Choi, Hee Seop	FLO	79	37	43	29	41	26	22	50	59	3	0.87
Choi, Hee Seop	LAN	17	40	37	41	35	53	48	23	35	8	0.59
Nunez, Abraham	FLO	21	42	30	73	71	28	22	50	9	2	0.04
Nunez, Abraham	KCA	54	38	30	40	55	37	27	61	24	3	0.82
Roberts, Dave	BOS	24	65	68	86	86	55	60	34	46	47	0.77
Roberts, Dave	LAN	57	61	69	75	85	58	50	26	45	9	0.55
Garciaparra, Nomar	BOS	35	54	59	58	59	47	45	80	25	77	0.61
Garciaparra, Nomar	CHN	41	59	64	48	53	60	62	74	62	32	0.68
Perez, Neifi	CHN	14	57	53	60	60	64	57	47	58	13	0.61
Perez, Neifi	SFN	82	62	59	66	52	64	60	77	61	17	0.59
Mientkiewicz, Doug	BOS	31	74	88	76	57	88	75	57	68	69	0.77
Mientkiewicz, Doug	MIN	74	68	84	71	44	89	70	46	54	17	0.61
Gonzalez, Alex	CHN	33	59	55	56	50	67	64	63	65	22	0.73
Gonzalez, Alex	MON	33	51	36	42	39	57	62	74	69	4	0.36
Encarnacion, Juan	FLO	44	69	64	63	62	80	76	83	57	4	0.61
Encarnacion, Juan	LAN	84	60	53	64	66	53	56	70	63	9	0.64
Borders, Pat	MIN	13	24	24	13	13	35	34	24	34	11	0.7
Borders, Pat	SEA	15	36	39	24	18	46	50	33	49	6	0.66
Gutierrez, Ricky	BOS	12	51	45	56	52	46	52	55	53	14	0.7
Gutierrez, Ricky	NYN	15	37	36	48	44	30	24	42	33	4	0.04
Olivo, Miguel	CHA	41	63	58	67	65	48	55	89	67	13	0.77
Olivo, Miguel	SEA	44	49	38	51	57	18	56	77	57	11	0.53
Aurilia, Rich	SDN	34	45	33	39	33	58	62	48	54	4	0.57
Aurilia, Rich	SEA	70	30	25	19	27	39	31	33	44	12	0.64
Garcia, Karim	BAL	17	21	15	21	23	27	14	27	24	20	0.62
Garcia, Karim	NYN	43	36	32	45	47	33	24	37	33	6	0.7
Ledee, Ricky	PHI	19	46	43	48	52	40	45	45	50	7	0.86
Ledee, Ricky	SFN	11	26	12	39	41	26	13	33	19	4	0.77
Davis, Ben	CHA	44	44	45	36	35	46	51	51	45	13	0.73
Davis, Ben	SEA	11	23	0	16	25	32	22	50	34	6	0.69
Alomar, Roberto	ARI	23	30	17	7	26	45	49	38	43	7	0.82
Alomar, Roberto	CHA	11	53	49	40	45	70	66	42	65	9	0.71
Mayne, Brent	ARI	26	23	52	8	8	37	13	16	19	3	0.79
Mayne, Brent	LAN	33	49	52	30	29	64	62	50	65	8	0.77

Updated: Dec 8, 2004

The league average for each of the seven traits of fielding is fixed at 50, with one standard deviation equal to 20 points. This means that a player with a trait value of 70 is in the top 16% in the league.

A player's name in gray means the player received less than 3 votes. A player's name in red received less than 6 votes.

The higher the agreement level, the more that the fans agreed with each other in the balloting. The league average is .71. The league low is around .40.