2004 The Scouting Report, By the Fans, For the Fans

Player Age GP Overall
Position-Neutral Instincts FirstStep Speed Hands Release Strength Accuracy Ballots Agreement
Level
Reyes, Jose 21 47 73 74 81 87 58 63 88 57 18 0.8
Wright, David 22 67 68 69 71 66 64 69 74 65 15 0.79
Cameron, Mike 31 132 68 83 84 74 62 57 52 47 24 0.78
Hidalgo, Richard 29 84 64 55 59 56 57 71 91 79 34 0.8
Wilson, Vance 31 43 58 65 51 34 59 67 65 71 11 0.78
Delgado, Wilson 32 38 52 46 49 47 56 61 50 63 9 0.86
Gutierrez, Ricky 34 15 48 43 54 51 43 45 51 48 18 0.55
Spencer, Shane 32 45 48 47 45 53 49 45 53 44 7 0.79
Garcia, Danny 24 38 47 48 51 53 49 47 37 37 10 0.76
Phillips, Jason 28 101 43 47 31 13 51 53 57 57 11 0.77
Valent, Eric 27 55 42 43 42 53 45 29 45 39 7 0.78
Keppinger, Jeff 24 29 41 43 36 39 33 41 42 59 5 0.83
Zeile, Todd 39 81 41 46 38 35 46 41 32 51 8 0.75
Wigginton, Ty 27 79 40 33 35 37 41 47 50 43 15 0.72
McEwing, Joe 32 38 39 38 42 44 35 41 32 36 10 0.72
Floyd, Cliff 32 96 30 33 27 33 32 28 29 28 18 0.59
Diaz, Victor 23 12 30 14 24 39 34 29 53 32 8 0.8
Williams, Gerald 38 30 26 17 32 35 28 32 7 30 3 0.64
Garcia, Karim 29 43 24 19 27 28 29 16 29 26 26 0.61
Matsui, Kazuo 29 108 24 18 33 58 19 10 16 10 18 0.67
Piazza, Mike 36 101 19 34 20 18 29 0 24 0 16 0.61

Updated (and Final): Apr 1, 2005

The league average for each of the seven traits of fielding is fixed at 50, with one standard deviation equal to 20 points. This means that a player with a trait value of 70 is in the top 16% in the league.

A player's name in gray means the player received less than 3 votes. A player's name in red received less than 6 votes.

The higher the agreement level, the more that the fans agreed with each other in the balloting. The league average is .71. The league low is around .40.

Player	Age	GP	Overall Position-Neutral	Instincts	FirstStep	Speed	Hands	Release	Strength	Accuracy	Ballots	Agreement Level
Reyes, Jose	21	47	73	74	81	87	58	63	88	57	18	0.8
Wright, David	22	67	68	69	71	66	64	69	74	65	15	0.79
Cameron, Mike	31	132	68	83	84	74	62	57	52	47	24	0.78
Hidalgo, Richard	29	84	64	55	59	56	57	71	91	79	34	0.8
Wilson, Vance	31	43	58	65	51	34	59	67	65	71	11	0.78
Delgado, Wilson	32	38	52	46	49	47	56	61	50	63	9	0.86
Gutierrez, Ricky	34	15	48	43	54	51	43	45	51	48	18	0.55
Spencer, Shane	32	45	48	47	45	53	49	45	53	44	7	0.79
Garcia, Danny	24	38	47	48	51	53	49	47	37	37	10	0.76
Phillips, Jason	28	101	43	47	31	13	51	53	57	57	11	0.77
Valent, Eric	27	55	42	43	42	53	45	29	45	39	7	0.78
Keppinger, Jeff	24	29	41	43	36	39	33	41	42	59	5	0.83
Zeile, Todd	39	81	41	46	38	35	46	41	32	51	8	0.75
Wigginton, Ty	27	79	40	33	35	37	41	47	50	43	15	0.72
McEwing, Joe	32	38	39	38	42	44	35	41	32	36	10	0.72
Floyd, Cliff	32	96	30	33	27	33	32	28	29	28	18	0.59
Diaz, Victor	23	12	30	14	24	39	34	29	53	32	8	0.8
Williams, Gerald	38	30	26	17	32	35	28	32	7	30	3	0.64
Garcia, Karim	29	43	24	19	27	28	29	16	29	26	26	0.61
Matsui, Kazuo	29	108	24	18	33	58	19	10	16	10	18	0.67
Piazza, Mike	36	101	19	34	20	18	29	0	24	0	16	0.61