2004 The Scouting Report, By the Fans, For the Fans

Player Age GP Overall
Position-Neutral Instincts FirstStep Speed Hands Release Strength Accuracy Ballots Agreement
Level
Beltran, Carlos 27 66 81 85 88 87 81 79 62 73 38 0.77
Blanco, Andres 20 18 72 77 76 71 79 69 68 52 7 0.7
Randa, Joe 35 117 61 67 61 47 64 66 57 66 10 0.81
DeJesus, David 25 89 58 64 63 67 62 50 44 48 10 0.78
Guiel, Aaron 32 34 54 50 55 50 53 55 53 62 7 0.81
Berroa, Angel 26 127 54 61 61 63 37 45 75 35 12 0.63
Gotay, Ruben 22 41 52 59 55 50 48 52 47 45 4 0.69
Castillo, Alberto 34 27 51 43 49 50 64 55 42 54 1 0.5
Gettis, Byron 24 15 49 43 49 50 37 41 68 69 1 0
Buck, John 24 64 46 53 46 26 52 41 56 51 8 0.53
Relaford, Desi 31 101 45 43 42 53 41 45 42 49 6 0.79
Graffanino, Tony 32 70 43 47 42 37 41 45 38 48 7 0.79
Lopez, Mendy 30 10 43 43 49 50 37 41 42 39 1 0
Nunez, Abraham 27 54 41 30 57 62 33 25 57 18 6 0.57
Mateo, Ruben 26 24 41 17 49 50 37 41 68 39 1 0
Stinnett, Kelly 34 17 40 43 49 28 37 41 42 39 1 0
Harvey, Ken 26 73 30 26 27 31 37 35 32 21 9 0.44
Brown, Dee 26 48 27 23 32 28 37 32 22 10 3 0.58
Berger, Brandon 29 10 27 17 24 28 37 27 42 25 2 0.93
Stairs, Matt 36 88 27 20 18 26 28 34 39 36 8 0.77
Santiago, Benito 39 46 23 30 24 14 17 34 16 25 3 0.23
Sweeney, Mike 31 52 21 17 21 24 4 20 32 34 12 0.75
Gonzalez, Juan 35 26 10 1 5 24 5 7 26 10 5 0.65

Updated (and Final): Apr 1, 2005

The league average for each of the seven traits of fielding is fixed at 50, with one standard deviation equal to 20 points. This means that a player with a trait value of 70 is in the top 16% in the league.

A player's name in gray means the player received less than 3 votes. A player's name in red received less than 6 votes.

The higher the agreement level, the more that the fans agreed with each other in the balloting. The league average is .71. The league low is around .40.

Player	Age	GP	Overall Position-Neutral	Instincts	FirstStep	Speed	Hands	Release	Strength	Accuracy	Ballots	Agreement Level
Beltran, Carlos	27	66	81	85	88	87	81	79	62	73	38	0.77
Blanco, Andres	20	18	72	77	76	71	79	69	68	52	7	0.7
Randa, Joe	35	117	61	67	61	47	64	66	57	66	10	0.81
DeJesus, David	25	89	58	64	63	67	62	50	44	48	10	0.78
Guiel, Aaron	32	34	54	50	55	50	53	55	53	62	7	0.81
Berroa, Angel	26	127	54	61	61	63	37	45	75	35	12	0.63
Gotay, Ruben	22	41	52	59	55	50	48	52	47	45	4	0.69
Castillo, Alberto	34	27	51	43	49	50	64	55	42	54	1	0.5
Gettis, Byron	24	15	49	43	49	50	37	41	68	69	1	0
Buck, John	24	64	46	53	46	26	52	41	56	51	8	0.53
Relaford, Desi	31	101	45	43	42	53	41	45	42	49	6	0.79
Graffanino, Tony	32	70	43	47	42	37	41	45	38	48	7	0.79
Lopez, Mendy	30	10	43	43	49	50	37	41	42	39	1	0
Nunez, Abraham	27	54	41	30	57	62	33	25	57	18	6	0.57
Mateo, Ruben	26	24	41	17	49	50	37	41	68	39	1	0
Stinnett, Kelly	34	17	40	43	49	28	37	41	42	39	1	0
Harvey, Ken	26	73	30	26	27	31	37	35	32	21	9	0.44
Brown, Dee	26	48	27	23	32	28	37	32	22	10	3	0.58
Berger, Brandon	29	10	27	17	24	28	37	27	42	25	2	0.93
Stairs, Matt	36	88	27	20	18	26	28	34	39	36	8	0.77
Santiago, Benito	39	46	23	30	24	14	17	34	16	25	3	0.23
Sweeney, Mike	31	52	21	17	21	24	4	20	32	34	12	0.75
Gonzalez, Juan	35	26	10	1	5	24	5	7	26	10	5	0.65