2004 The Scouting Report, By the Fans, For the Fans

Player Age GP Overall
Position-Neutral Instincts FirstStep Speed Hands Release Strength Accuracy Ballots Agreement
Level
Helton, Todd 31 147 73 80 68 50 86 92 62 63 5 0.8
Walker, Larry 38 30 72 78 66 55 67 83 80 82 17 0.8
Castilla, Vinny 37 143 63 56 53 32 82 83 76 74 6 0.65
Clayton, Royce 34 138 61 56 61 67 69 64 46 64 6 0.78
Gonzalez, Luis A. 25 71 56 69 61 50 28 55 59 69 2 0.88
Wilson, Preston 30 48 47 69 40 42 55 50 42 20 3 0.45
Burnitz, Jeromy 35 133 47 52 44 39 60 41 46 44 6 0.51
Miles, Aaron 28 114 46 59 49 50 32 52 26 39 5 0.71
Piedra, Jorge 25 24 44 56 49 50 51 13 42 39 1 0.21
Barmes, Clint 25 15 39 34 55 44 44 34 29 17 3 0.67
Holliday, Matt 24 102 37 22 39 54 37 24 57 34 5 0.71
Closser, J.D. 24 29 31 43 24 28 10 0 93 39 1 0.14
Johnson, Charles 33 83 26 34 8 14 19 41 50 30 3 0.57
Greene, Todd 33 47 26 17 12 18 51 32 50 10 2 0.85
Hawpe, Brad 25 27 22 17 24 50 10 13 42 0 1 0
Pellow, Kit 31 26 11 17 12 18 0 13 16 0 1 0.21
Reyes, Rene 26 15 5 0 24 7 0 0 0 0 1 0
Hocking, Dennis 34 22 1 0 0 7 0 0 0 0 1 0

Updated (and Final): Apr 1, 2005

The league average for each of the seven traits of fielding is fixed at 50, with one standard deviation equal to 20 points. This means that a player with a trait value of 70 is in the top 16% in the league.

A player's name in gray means the player received less than 3 votes. A player's name in red received less than 6 votes.

The higher the agreement level, the more that the fans agreed with each other in the balloting. The league average is .71. The league low is around .40.

Player	Age	GP	Overall Position-Neutral	Instincts	FirstStep	Speed	Hands	Release	Strength	Accuracy	Ballots	Agreement Level
Helton, Todd	31	147	73	80	68	50	86	92	62	63	5	0.8
Walker, Larry	38	30	72	78	66	55	67	83	80	82	17	0.8
Castilla, Vinny	37	143	63	56	53	32	82	83	76	74	6	0.65
Clayton, Royce	34	138	61	56	61	67	69	64	46	64	6	0.78
Gonzalez, Luis A.	25	71	56	69	61	50	28	55	59	69	2	0.88
Wilson, Preston	30	48	47	69	40	42	55	50	42	20	3	0.45
Burnitz, Jeromy	35	133	47	52	44	39	60	41	46	44	6	0.51
Miles, Aaron	28	114	46	59	49	50	32	52	26	39	5	0.71
Piedra, Jorge	25	24	44	56	49	50	51	13	42	39	1	0.21
Barmes, Clint	25	15	39	34	55	44	44	34	29	17	3	0.67
Holliday, Matt	24	102	37	22	39	54	37	24	57	34	5	0.71
Closser, J.D.	24	29	31	43	24	28	10	0	93	39	1	0.14
Johnson, Charles	33	83	26	34	8	14	19	41	50	30	3	0.57
Greene, Todd	33	47	26	17	12	18	51	32	50	10	2	0.85
Hawpe, Brad	25	27	22	17	24	50	10	13	42	0	1	0
Pellow, Kit	31	26	11	17	12	18	0	13	16	0	1	0.21
Reyes, Rene	26	15	5	0	24	7	0	0	0	0	1	0
Hocking, Dennis	34	22	1	0	0	7	0	0	0	0	1	0