2004 The Scouting Report, By the Fans, For the Fans

Player Age GP Overall
Position-Neutral Instincts FirstStep Speed Hands Release Strength Accuracy Ballots Agreement
Level
Reese, Pokey 31 73 84 84 91 83 86 88 64 83 83 0.82
Cabrera, Orlando 30 55 78 83 83 73 75 81 71 78 104 0.82
Mientkiewicz, Doug 30 31 73 87 75 55 89 75 55 66 89 0.73
Roberts, Dave 32 24 65 68 85 86 55 59 33 46 56 0.74
Kapler, Gabe 29 83 64 59 67 71 56 64 71 60 71 0.73
Varitek, Jason 32 118 62 77 58 49 69 63 54 58 66 0.68
Mueller, Bill 33 105 60 68 58 50 58 65 55 63 82 0.78
McCarty, David 35 39 59 64 53 41 71 63 58 61 43 0.67
Mirabelli, Doug 34 42 58 68 38 30 73 67 69 67 54 0.72
Damon, Johnny 31 140 58 72 77 83 66 43 2 32 100 0.71
Nixon, Trot 30 34 57 64 52 49 62 60 59 55 80 0.77
Garciaparra, Nomar 31 35 55 60 55 58 50 50 78 35 111 0.58
Bellhorn, Mark 30 129 52 52 46 43 49 63 52 63 95 0.74
Gutierrez, Ricky 34 12 48 43 54 51 43 45 51 48 18 0.55
Youkilis, Kevin 25 56 44 45 41 41 43 44 49 50 57 0.82
Crespo, Cesar 25 24 35 25 46 52 25 30 34 30 33 0.58
Ramirez, Manny 32 121 33 28 28 36 19 35 52 44 90 0.62
Daubach, Brian 32 17 32 38 28 27 31 28 37 34 21 0.73
Millar, Kevin 33 117 31 33 30 27 33 26 39 27 75 0.71
Ortiz, David 29 29 27 35 17 15 28 28 38 37 52 0.67

Updated (and Final): Apr 1, 2005

The league average for each of the seven traits of fielding is fixed at 50, with one standard deviation equal to 20 points. This means that a player with a trait value of 70 is in the top 16% in the league.

A player's name in gray means the player received less than 3 votes. A player's name in red received less than 6 votes.

The higher the agreement level, the more that the fans agreed with each other in the balloting. The league average is .71. The league low is around .40.

Player	Age	GP	Overall Position-Neutral	Instincts	FirstStep	Speed	Hands	Release	Strength	Accuracy	Ballots	Agreement Level
Reese, Pokey	31	73	84	84	91	83	86	88	64	83	83	0.82
Cabrera, Orlando	30	55	78	83	83	73	75	81	71	78	104	0.82
Mientkiewicz, Doug	30	31	73	87	75	55	89	75	55	66	89	0.73
Roberts, Dave	32	24	65	68	85	86	55	59	33	46	56	0.74
Kapler, Gabe	29	83	64	59	67	71	56	64	71	60	71	0.73
Varitek, Jason	32	118	62	77	58	49	69	63	54	58	66	0.68
Mueller, Bill	33	105	60	68	58	50	58	65	55	63	82	0.78
McCarty, David	35	39	59	64	53	41	71	63	58	61	43	0.67
Mirabelli, Doug	34	42	58	68	38	30	73	67	69	67	54	0.72
Damon, Johnny	31	140	58	72	77	83	66	43	2	32	100	0.71
Nixon, Trot	30	34	57	64	52	49	62	60	59	55	80	0.77
Garciaparra, Nomar	31	35	55	60	55	58	50	50	78	35	111	0.58
Bellhorn, Mark	30	129	52	52	46	43	49	63	52	63	95	0.74
Gutierrez, Ricky	34	12	48	43	54	51	43	45	51	48	18	0.55
Youkilis, Kevin	25	56	44	45	41	41	43	44	49	50	57	0.82
Crespo, Cesar	25	24	35	25	46	52	25	30	34	30	33	0.58
Ramirez, Manny	32	121	33	28	28	36	19	35	52	44	90	0.62
Daubach, Brian	32	17	32	38	28	27	31	28	37	34	21	0.73
Millar, Kevin	33	117	31	33	30	27	33	26	39	27	75	0.71
Ortiz, David	29	29	27	35	17	15	28	28	38	37	52	0.67