Background
Welcome to the Seventh Annual Fans' Scouting Report. For those looking for past results, go here.
Baseball's fans are very perceptive. Take a large group of them, and they can pick out the final standings with the best of them. They can forecast the performance of players as well as those guys with rather sophisticated forecasting engines. Bill James, in one of his later Abstracts, had the fans vote in for the ranking of the best to worst players by position. And they did a darn good job.
There is an enormous amount of untapped knowledge here. There are 70 million fans at MLB parks every year, and a whole lot more watching the games on television. When I was a teenager, I had no problem picking out Tim Wallach as a great fielding 3B, a few years before MLB coaches did so. And, judging by the quantity of non-stop standing ovations Wallach received, I wasn't the only one in Montreal whose eyes did not deceive him. Rondel White, Marquis Grissom, Larry Walker, Andre Dawson, Hubie Brooks, Ellis Valentine. We don't need stats to tell us which of these does not belong.
The Project
What I would like to do now is tap that pool of talent. I want you to tell me what your eyes see. I want you to tell me how good or bad a fielder is. Go down, and start selecting the team(s) that you watch all the time. For any player that you've seen play in at least 10 games in 2009, I want you to judge his performance in 7 specific fielding categories.
Try to judge 'average' not as an average player at that position, but an average player at any position. If you think that Willie Bloomquist has an average arm, then mark him as average, regardless if you've seen him play 2B, SS, 3B, LF, or CF.
DO NOT CONSIDER THE POSITION THE PLAYER PLAYS!
DO NOT CONSIDER THE POSITION THE PLAYER PLAYS!
DO NOT CONSIDER THE POSITION THE PLAYER PLAYS!
If you don't have an opinion on a particular characteristic of that player, then go on to the next characteristic for that player. This applies especially for you TV watchers, and you can't tell how well Andruw Jones can read the ball off the bat.
And, most importantly, do not, absolutely do not, look at any numbers. Don't look at his fielding percentage, range factor, zone rating, UZR, or anything else that someone else is telling you. I just want you to rely on your eyes. You are the scout. I need you to rely completely on your own observations.
We know the fans know what they are talking about. We know they know how to observe good and bad fielding. Now, I just want to know what the fans know. And, hopefully, so do you.
Note: The rosters are based on any player with at least 90 innings played for a particular team in 2009. If you have any write-in candidates beyond that, tell me.
| View Results | Player Counts | Player-Tools Counts | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Arizona Diamondbacks | 24 Results | 186 | 1209 | |
| Atlanta Braves | 44 Results | 390 | 2591 | |
| Baltimore Orioles | 42 Results | 456 | 2990 | |
| Boston Red Sox | 92 Results | 823 | 5377 | |
| Chicago Cubs | 80 Results | 806 | 5052 | |
| Chicago White Sox | 72 Results | 685 | 4554 | |
| Cincinnati Reds | 51 Results | 511 | 3333 | |
| Cleveland Indians | 41 Results | 348 | 2244 | |
| Colorado Rockies | 51 Results | 532 | 3446 | |
| Detroit Tigers | 72 Results | 816 | 5437 | |
| Florida Marlins | 24 Results | 245 | 1649 | |
| Houston Astros | 29 Results | 263 | 1750 | |
| Kansas City Royals | 28 Results | 296 | 1955 | |
| Los Angeles Angels | 40 Results | 443 | 2830 | |
| Los Angeles Dodgers | 110 Results | 915 | 5914 | |
| Milwaukee Brewers | 38 Results | 376 | 2552 | |
| Minnesota Twins | 65 Results | 648 | 4285 | |
| New York Mets | 119 Results | 1213 | 7851 | |
| New York Yankees | 108 Results | 988 | 6346 | |
| Oakland Athletics | 53 Results | 536 | 3450 | |
| Philadelphia Phillies | 54 Results | 469 | 2959 | |
| Pittsburgh Pirates | 65 Results | 760 | 5063 | |
| San Diego Padres | 27 Results | 211 | 1400 | |
| San Francisco Giants | 57 Results | 621 | 3994 | |
| Seattle Mariners | 201 Results | 1961 | 12657 | |
| St. Louis Cardinals | 96 Results | 910 | 5828 | |
| Tampa Bay Rays | 92 Results | 955 | 6193 | |
| Texas Rangers | 21 Results | 200 | 1305 | |
| Toronto Blue Jays | 70 Results | 638 | 4085 | |
| Washington Nationals | 32 Results | 227 | 1486 | |
| SEE ALL PLAYERS | 1898 Results | 18428 | 119785 | |